
The 2019 Browns: A Portrait of Fan Frustration and Loyalty
By Nick Cammett
The Cleveland Browns entered the 2019 season picked by many to contend for not only a division title but in some eyes, the Super Bowl. Needless to say, 2019 has been somewhat of a let down for not only the Browns but their avid fan base. Nick Cammett reports from FirstEnergy Stadium on how the Browns and their fans are handling the sluggish start and potential saving of their season.
At the halfway point of the 2019 NFL season the Cleveland Browns are well behind where many pundits, experts and fans thought they would be.
After eight games, the Browns were 2-6 following an ugly 24-19 loss to the hapless Denver Broncos. After being on the road 4 of the last 5 games, the Browns return home for 3 pivotal games in 21 days. First up, the Buffalo Bills, a team on the rise and a matchup that presents some challenges to the Browns and their fans.
“I feel pretty badly about Freddie Kitchens,” one fan said. “I feel like he’s not developing Baker Mayfield into the quarterback he should be. For his second year, I didn’t see the jump that I wanted to.”
That sentiment is matched by many fans. After the offseason acquisition of wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., the belief that the Browns went from basement dwellers to title contenders put Browns fans in an odd position, as position of hope. That hope was quickly turned to skepticism after ugly losses and an ugly couple of wins. Those games coupled with bad performances by the team’s stars like Baker Mayfield, Beckham, Jarvis Landry and rookie head coach Freddie Kitchens began the old refrain of ‘same old Browns’. A mantra uttered by the most jaded of fans who have endured 30 plus years of nothing but losing. Yet they still show up, 4 1/2 hours before a game.
“I guess because I’ve got nothing to lose,” said one fan. “As a Browns fan I’ve already lost everything so I’ve got nothing to lose.
After a close victory over Buffalo, many fans shared a reluctant joy after seeing something that resembled a complete win.
“We skated by the Bills,” said another fan. “A wins a win anyways.”
The jubilance of a win was manifested into optimism within a few days because of the Browns’ Thursday night game against the rival Pittsburgh Steelers, a team that is also struggling this season.
“ The season as a whole we’re what 3-6. It’s been more bad than good. I hope they’re starting to figure things out, but tonight’s gonna prove a lot.”
“ They’re starting an eight-game winning streak, they’re going to the playoffs. Absolutely. They’re gonna kick the Steelers’ ass tonight, this is like a playoff game.”
“I’ll tell you what, we have the schedule to do it. They have the opportunity to do it but they haven’t shown me enough, the coaching staff hasn’t shown me enough. I don’t put it on the players because we have all the talent in the world to make a run to the playoffs, but Freddie Kitchens, man. He’s a new coach so I don’t want to get on him too much but the team just hasn’t shown my enough where I think they can go on an 8-0, 7-0 run you know what I’m saying? It would be a lot of fun and it would reenergize this city.”
The Browns vanquished Pittsburgh 21-7, but the win felt more of a loss after an incident in the final minutes in which all-pro defensive end Myles Garrett hit Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph over the head with his own helmet. This spurred an on field melee between the teams. Garrett was suspended for the remainder of the season and the Browns push for the playoffs has begun to seem more bleak.
After a 41-24 win over the Miami Dolphins, the Browns completed their 3 game home stand and continued on the road toward a wild card birth. The Dolphins game showed fans the closest thing to what was expected of this Browns team all year. Confidence was high, and a rematch with the Steelers was on the horizon. If the Browns wanted to be considered in the playoff chase, they’d have to win in Pittsburgh. Something that hasn’t happened in 15 years.
“You know as a fan base I’m happy that we’ve rallied behind the Browns. It’s probably a result of how much hype there was coming into the season.”
Entering the game, chants of “Pittsburgh started it” and “Pittsburgh’s gonna finish” it bellowed through Heinz Field. The Browns jumped out to a commanding 10-0 lead, seemingly in control, but like always, Browns things happened and suddenly they were leaving Pittsburgh with yet another loss.
“All offseason it’s in Dorsey we trust every move, but the hire of Freddie has made me question it. Freddie’s a great guy, on the surface he seems like a guy who gets along with the players, can manage a locker room but what he’s shown this year just hasn’t proved that.”
Now at 5-7, the Browns face a tough road if they are to sneak into the playoffs. Not only would they have to run the table but there will be a heavy reliance on four other teams to fall to record worse than theirs. Anything is possible but remember, this is the Browns we’re talking about.